Need Help!~ Mail Forwarding via Domain

I'm struggling with an issue at work. We've launched a second website and I need info@A and info@B to rout to separate places 

We're running Exchange 2013 and it won't let me create 2 different users with 'info' as the username. I'm good with the Forwarding Rules integrated into the Exchange GUI but I can't get it to forward by the Recipients Domain Name.

I've tried every variation of 'test@domain.com', '@domain.com', 'domain.com' 'domain' for all the following options:

• The Domain Is
• The Recipient Includes
• The Recipient Matches
• Any Recipient Includes
• Any Recipient Matches

Nothing has worked, and I need to get this running ASAP so I'll appreciate any help I can get.

Thanks!~